| # | Mayor | Picture | Term | Party |
|---|
| 1st | George O. Brastow | | January 1, 1872 – January 5, 1874 |
| 2nd | William Henry Furber | | January 5, 1874 – January 3, 1876 |
| 3rd | Austin Belknap | | January 3, 1876 – January 1878 |
| 4th | George A.
Bruce | | January 1878 – 1880 | Republican |
| 5th | John Adams Cummings | | 1881–1884 |
| 6th | Mark F. Burns | | 1885–1888 | Republican |
| 7th | Charles G.
Pope | | 1889–1891 | Republican |
| 8th | William H. Hodgkins | | 1892 – January 6, 1896 | Republican |
| 9th | Albion A. Perry | | January 6, 1896 – 1898 | Citizens and Republican |
| 10th | George O.
Proctor | | 1899–1900 | Republican |
| 11th | Edward Glines | | January, 1901 – January 4, 1904 | Republican |
| 12th | Leonard B. Chandler | | January 4, 1904 – January 1, 1906 | Republican |
| 13th | Charles Arnold Grimmons | January 1, 1906 – January 4, 1909 | Republican |
| 14th | John M.
Woods | | January 4, 1909 – January 2, 1911 | Republican |
| 15th | Char
|